Exploring ChatGPT's Artistic Insight: A Deep Dive
Written on
Chapter 1: Introduction to ChatGPT as an Art Critic
For an extended period, we have been captivated by the potential of ChatGPT in the realm of art criticism. The introduction of the ability to upload data in ChatGPT's paid version piqued our interest further, especially following the September update that enhanced its image analysis capabilities. While we have always appreciated art, our engagement with it has mostly been as admirers rather than creators, enjoying visits to museums and reading art literature, albeit without an overwhelming obsession.
The launch of DALL-E 2 last year significantly transformed our artistic journey, despite our initial ignorance of its predecessor, DALL-E. This innovative tool opened up new visual avenues for us to explore, prompting a creative adventure that remains ongoing. Interestingly, DALL-E 2 emerged just when we were seeking a new artistic outlet, ultimately enriching our lives in ways we hadn't anticipated.
After a period of being engrossed in work and daily life, we have rekindled our passion for art. With our personal reflections shared, let's focus on our primary experiment, which forms part of our ongoing 'explorAItion.' Art critiques were never our forte, neither in our educational pursuits nor afterward. Our interest lies in deciphering and appreciating the stories within artworks, revealing subtle details that often go unnoticed—such as the two angels delicately etched in Caspar David Friedrich's "The Cemetery Entrance."
We seldom consume art reviews, yet we pondered:
How effectively does ChatGPT analyze images of art?
If you would like us to update this article with additional results from ChatGPT's image recreation based on the identified prompts, please leave a comment. Enjoy the exploration!
Art Selection for Analysis
Choosing artworks for this investigation can either be a protracted endeavor or a swift selection process. For the sake of brevity, we opted for the latter, selecting pieces that resonate with us. The artworks we examined include:
- Leonardo da Vinci: Mona Lisa
- Michelangelo: The Creation of Adam
- Edvard Munch: The Scream
- Eugène Delacroix: Liberty Leading the People
- Banksy: Girl with Balloon
- Andy Warhol: Marilyn Monroe (1967, screenprint, Edition of 250)
- AI Generated: A close-up of a Vietnamese old man's face
- AI Generated: Experience the aerial view magic of Istanbul
- AI Generated (Art of AI): Geometric Hallucinations in the Desert
- AI Generated (Art of AI): Flowrelia
Experimental Framework
AI System: OpenAI ChatGPT-4 (paid version) / September 25 Version
Prompt: A consistent prompt was utilized for generating all images.
Uploaded files: Images were internally identified by numbers without revealing their titles.
The first video titled "Creating My Art Critic: Building a Personal ChatGPT App for Artists" showcases the process of developing a customized ChatGPT application for artists, highlighting its potential as an art critique tool.
Artworks Analysis
#1 Leonardo da Vinci: Mona Lisa
Title: "The Enigmatic Smile"
Description: This artwork features a woman with a serene expression and a subtle smile set against a distant landscape of winding roads and misty mountains.
AI Classification:
- Features Extracted:
- Human facial features: Eyes, nose, mouth, eyebrows.
- Background elements: Landscape, mountains, water.
- Color palette: Earthy tones, subtle contrasts.
Art Analysis:
The painting beautifully combines the human figure with nature, employing the sfumato technique to create depth and lifelikeness. The muted colors and enigmatic smile invite endless interpretation.
Artist's Motivation & Message:
The artist captures human emotion's essence, symbolizing inner peace and the transient nature of feelings.
Community Ratings:
- Art Community: ★★★★★
- Broad Audience: ★★★★★
- European Audience: ★★★★★
- North American Audience: ★★★★★
Critiques:
- Negative: Some view it as overrated and lacking contemporary relevance.
- Positive: It represents timeless human emotions, bridging the past and present.
The second video titled "I Interview ChatGPT About Ethics of AI ART: HE IS RIGHT" delves into the ethical considerations surrounding AI-generated art, providing insights into the complexities of the subject.
Chapter 2: Further Analysis and Insights
In this chapter, we will continue to explore the various artworks and the corresponding analyses provided by ChatGPT, enhancing our understanding of its capabilities as an art critic and the implications of AI in the creative domain.