Mastering the Three-Pass Reading Technique for Scientific Papers

Chapter 1: Introduction to Efficient Reading Techniques

In the realm of knowledge work, particularly for data scientists, the necessity of sifting through numerous scientific papers is commonplace. I often find myself combing the internet for relevant articles related to my projects. Initially, I might encounter around 15 to 20 papers, but only a handful truly warrant a deeper dive. Over time, I began to notice that much of my reading felt unproductive—perhaps 70% to 80% of it was not as beneficial as I had hoped.

This realization prompted me to refine my reading strategy, leading to the development of the three-pass reading and concept mapping method. While this approach is tailored to scientific literature, it can be applied to other types of texts as well.

Preparations for Reading

Before delving into a paper, I print it along with a reading template to facilitate a structured approach. This template helps me maintain consistency in my reading and allows me to log insights and action items. Although the template reflects my focus on data science, you can adapt it to fit your specific field.

You can download the reading template here: PDFReading template — print and fold.

Pass 1: Concept Discovery and Knowledge Matching

The first pass focuses on determining whether a paper merits further attention. I typically skim the title, abstract, introduction, headings, bullet points, figures, and conclusion. During this initial review, I highlight key concepts, note essential figures, and assess how the paper enhances my existing knowledge. I might refer to previous concept maps or outline new ones as necessary, dedicating approximately 30 to 45 minutes to this stage—less if the abstract indicates the paper isn't relevant.

In this video, learn how to effectively read and comprehend research papers using a three-pass technique, enhancing your understanding of complex texts.

Pass 2: Concept Understanding and Mapping

During the second pass, I scrutinize the entire paper in detail to grasp the concepts and their interrelations. This step aims to contextualize the content within my existing knowledge framework. I also take note of references to explore additional relevant literature via Google Scholar, especially for papers older than a year. Using the TODO checklist in my template helps manage multiple readings efficiently. Ultimately, I decide whether the paper's insights warrant a final pass based on their relevance to my current projects.

This video covers the basics of reading academic papers, focusing on Keshav's Three-Pass Approach, which simplifies the research process.

Pass 3: Reimplementation and Results Reproduction

The final pass involves practical application, such as reimplementing algorithms or replicating study results. If I am not dealing with a scientific paper, I look for actionable steps that provide practical experience with the material. This phase emphasizes experiential learning.

Post-Processing Notes

At the conclusion of each pass, I digitize my notes, allowing me to discard the printed copies while making my insights searchable. I utilize a Python script to create a cover page, merge it with the original PDF, and organize it into relevant folders on my local drive. This last step aids in integrating the paper into my personal knowledge management system, where I use tools like the Visual Understanding Environment (VUE) and Obsidian for more complex texts.

Chapter 2: A Practical Example—Survey on Self-Supervised Learning

Currently, I am exploring various unsupervised learning methods, particularly self-supervised learning. When venturing into new subjects, I often start with a recent survey article, as it provides a comprehensive overview and a framework for categorizing sub-topics, serving as a solid foundation for my concept map.

Preparations for Reading the Survey

Upon identifying the relevant paper, I place it in a "To_print" folder to gather multiple articles for later review. After printing, I label the folder with the current date for easy reference. This organization helps streamline my reading process as I continue collecting interesting materials.

Pass 1 of Reading the Survey

During my first pass, I discovered that the core concept of self-supervised learning involves using a pretext process to assign pseudo-labels to training samples. I identified four main applications and noted them, along with related data types. Ultimately, I concluded that this paper warranted a second pass, as it contained valuable insights for my personal knowledge management system regarding AI.

Notes After Pass 1

Following the digitalization of my notes, I organized them for clarity, including TODOs for further exploration.

Pass 2 of Reading the Survey

In the second pass, I concentrated on the critical pretext process that distinguishes self-supervised learning from other paradigms. The paper included pseudocode for these methods, which is particularly relevant to my work with time-series data. Although I found valuable information, I opted not to conduct a third pass since it lacked specific methods.

Post-Processing the Survey Notes

I use Adobe Acrobat to highlight key passages, saving the PDF with these annotations for future reference. The new knowledge gained is instrumental in updating my concept maps, which I continue to refine as I delve deeper into this field.

Conclusions

While the three-pass reading method may seem elaborate and time-consuming, its value becomes apparent after several applications. As I read more papers, the volume of new knowledge diminishes, reducing the workload for future readings. I typically conduct second and third passes on a small percentage of papers—approximately 80% only require the first pass.

The effort invested in concept mapping pays off significantly. As a knowledge worker, my expertise enhances my value to my employer. The structured approach of concept mapping makes accessing knowledge more manageable, ensuring that the insights I gather are preserved for future use.

jamelkenya.com